Elementary
Today's review is the new Guy Ritchie directed Sherlock Holmes. Sherlock Holmes stars Robert Downey Jr as the titular character and Jude Law as his partner is sleuthing, Dr. Watson. In this film, Holmes and Watson try to solve a series of murders that occur after the execution of master of the dark arts, Lord Blackwood.
This Sherlock Holmes is not your father's Sherlock Holmes. It is a more physical, more bedraggled Holmes played with a great deal of humor but no shortness of logic reasoning to solve his predicaments. Not as sophisticated and smooth as Basil Rathbone's iconic Holmes, Downey brings a freshness to the role. His English accent is steady and convincing, at least to these Yankee ears. I would expect nothing less from a thespian of Downey's caliber.
Jude Law plays Watson like a pro. He wants to move on with his life and his fiance but can not say no to the thrill of the hunt that he so much enjoys with his old friend. Downey and Law are perfectly matched in this film as they breath life into these two characters that are well known to the over forty crowd but in a way that can make Holmes and Watson an ongoing franchise for the under forty crowd.
The only complaint I have is the film relies so much on CGI for scenery and backgrounds that they are forced to create a grainy London of the late 1800s in which there is no sunshine. CGI holds up better that way but it is distracting to this film fan.
There have been complaints that this Sherlock Holmes is too much like a super hero and less like the detective of literature and films of the 1940s. I watched the Basil Rathbone/Nigel Bruce films as a child on Sundays but I don't recall them as much as I'd like to. Given that, Basil Rathbone created such an iconic Holmes that I can fully understand fans of that version being upset like many Godzilla fans were in 1998 when the icon monster was given an unrecognizable facelift that left almost all fans disappointed.
If you change an iconic character to update it for a current generation you will almost certainly disappoint the fans of the original who have certain expectations going in. That may be the case with Sherlock Holmes but since I am not as familiar with the iconic portrayal, I thoroughly enjoyed this version.
I give Sherlock Holmes four Billys.

Facebook


In 1998, I was fortunate to have fate introduce my family to the wonder of 

